Categories
initiative, referendum, and recall judiciary

Right to Sign, Restored

An attempt to kill the right of statewide citizen initiative in Oklahoma has failed. By a 5-4 decision, the state supreme court ruled SB1027 unconstitutional and void.

Among other burdens, the legislation sought to require that no more than ten percent of petition signatures could come from a county with more than 400,000 residents.

KGOU reports that this cap would have been imposed on only two counties, those of Tulsa and Oklahoma, who together “could contribute only 20% of a petition’s signatures despite being home to nearly 37% of Oklahoma residents.”

We’re trying to get rural voters more involved, burbled bill backers. Also, petitioners who secure signatures from only a few counties are “corrupt,” asserted State Senator David Bullard.

The court’s decision notes that the “supposed goal of incorporating more rural voters at the signature gathering stage would impose a significant burden on the right of petition. The caps seek to achieve the inclusion of some by requiring the exclusion of others. . . . By denying qualified legal voters the right to participate in the petition process, the caps violate Oklahomans’ constitutional right of petition.”

A dissenting judge replied that no one who wanted to sign a petition would have been stopped by SB1027. It’s just that their valid signatures might have been tossed as irrelevant later . . . that’s all.

So the idea was you could sign. But it would have been as if you hadn’t were you one of those benighted post-ten percent signers. 

. . . The virtue of which still eludes me.

This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.


PDF for printing

Illustration created with Nano Banana

See all recent commentary
(simplified and organized)
See recent popular posts

Categories
Thought

John Taylor

We must reason from a comparison between general or universal facts, and not from a contemplation of temporary exceptions, to come at truth; and when we discover that an absolute power over property, though occasionally exercised for the attainment of praise-worthy ends, is yet constantly attended by general evils, infinitely outweighing such particular benefits; we forbear to draw our conclusion from the partial cases, or decide erroneously.

John Taylor of Caroline, Construction Construed, and Constitutions Vindicated (1820).
Categories
Today

A First in Washington

The United States Congress held its first session in Washington, D.C., on November 17, 1800.

Under the U.S. Constitution, before Congress convened in Washington, D.C., it met in only two cities:

  • New York City (1789–1790) — at Federal Hall, where George Washington was inaugurated as the first president.
  • Philadelphia (1790–1800) — at Congress Hall, per the Residence Act of 1790, which designated the city as the temporary capital while the new federal district along the Potomac was being prepared.

Before that, the Continental Congresses were rather itinerant, sometimes on the run, meeting in many cities.

Categories
initiative, referendum, and recall media and media people

Voters Win in Missouri

The St. Louis Post-Dispatch, as giddy as a coke fiend in a locked DEA evidence room, is egging on rogue politicians. Missouri’s have threatened to sue . . . to undo a citizen initiative passed to prevent politicians from easily undoing citizen initiatives.

“I could see lawsuits being filed against Amendment 6, saying that it is unconstitutional,” says Missouri Secretary of State Denny Hoskins. “It takes too much power away from the elected state reps [and] state senators.”

“Go for it,” the Dispatch responds.

Missouri’s Pulitzer-founded paper supports the incumbent-hated measure but thinks that politicians pondering litigation would be doing the equivalent of running on banana peels. The Dispatch looks forward to watching them slip on those banana peels.

Unfortunately, seemingly hopeless attempts at political sabotage sometimes succeed. So I can’t be as eager as the Dispatch to see an actual lawsuit.

Missouri voters passed the measure in question, Amendment 6, by a 60-40 majority. It prohibits the legislature “from repealing or amending a citizen initiative unless at least 80% of both the House and Senate vote to refer a proposed change to the ballot, and voters then approve the change.” 

The new law also prohibits the state legislature from making changes to weaken the citizen initiative — just like those sought in August by incumbent-referred, voter-trounced Amendment 4. It would have required a Yes from a majority of voters in every one of the state’s eight congressional districts, not just statewide, to pass a citizen initiative. 

By passing Amendment 6, Missouri voters have won a great victory. And I don’t think that a lawsuit against it can succeed.

This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.


PDF for printing

Illustration created with Nano Banana

See all recent commentary
(simplified and organized)
See recent popular posts

Categories
Thought

Brandeis

The intensity and complexity of life, attendant upon advancing civilization, have rendered necessary some retreat from the world.

Judge Louis Brandeis, “The Right to Privacy,” 4 Harvard Law Review. 193, 196 (1890).
Categories
Today

The Fed Begins

On November 16, 1914, the Federal Reserve Bank of the United States officially opened.

Categories
Update

Bolsonaro

On November 3, Paul Jacob discussed a presidential candidate on the run — Flávio Bolsonaro, a Brazilian politician running away from his country, for fear of prosecution and persecution:

Flávio’s father has been in prison since 2024 for supposedly plotting a coup against Lula.

And this October, after the results of the second round of the presidential election were announced, the Lula government tried to prevent the son from traveling by acting to confiscate his passports. But Flávio Bolsonaro saw the writing on the wall and got out before he could be arrested for having the temerity to run for president.

Since then, Bolsonaro has given a few interviews, including with the New York Times and Glenn Greenwald. “Flávio Bolsonaro is now living in exile in the United States after losing Brazil’s recent presidential election three weeks ago,” explains The Epoch Times, in the editorial preface to its video interview with the exile.

He believes there was significant fraud in the voting process. President Lula da Silva disagrees. 

In Brazil, there can be a big price to pay for claiming election fraud. Bolsonaro’s father, former President Jair Bolsonaro, is currently serving a 27-year sentence related to his efforts to challenge the results of the 2022 presidential election. He was convicted of attempted coup d’état and attempted violent abolition of the democratic rule of law, among other crimes.

Glenn Greenwald’s interview is notable in part because of the hysterical reaction of many leftists, arguing that by merely interviewing Bolsonaro, Greenwald proves that he is a fascist or something. Greenwald responded to these goofy accusations on his System Update program on Rumble.

On Friday, CounterPunch published criticism of Greenwald and the whole affair, make of it what you will.

Categories
Thought

John Taylor

I renounce the idea sometimes advanced that the state governments ever were or continue to be, sovereign or unlimited. If the people are sovereign, their governments cannot also be sovereign.

John Taylor of Caroline, as quoted in Walter E. Volkomer, ed., The Liberal Tradition in American Thought (G. P. Putnam Sons, 1969).
Categories
Today

The Articles

On November 15, 1777, after 16 months of debate, the Continental Congress approved the Articles of Confederation.

Categories
Update

Starship Makes Progress

Paul Jacob has been covering Elon Musk and his various enterprises here for over a decade. The rocket biz developments have been especially interesting, for by outsourcing the production of rockets and launches, NASA has been able to gain some cost-cutting efficiencies. And above that, SpaceX, Musk’s rocket company, has been making money hand over fist not just with government contracts: Private businesses have hired the company, too.

Business appears to be booming, in the words of The Epoch Times:

SpaceX successfully sent its Starship on its most ambitious mission yet: a roughly 22-hour-long mission that will set a new personal record time in orbit, with the goal of the upper stage making its first return to the launchpad.

While controlled capture of the booster stage failed — the booster’s land capture was aborted and the rocket was re-routed for a controlled drop into the sea, the safe return of the upper stage is on track for this afternoon — around 4:17–4:20 p.m. EST (3:17 p.m. Texas time) at Starbase, about 22.5 hours after liftoff.

Meanwhile, Democrats — hot off mid-term wins, and apparently eager to engage in overreach — increasingly call for prosecution of Elon Musk and government takeover of SpaceX!

And it’s just not a matter for ninnies and nobodies on social media. Before the election a Clinton Era relic made the case: “Former Clinton Labor Secretary Robert Reich called on Democrats to target billionaire Elon Musk if they regain control of Congress in the midterm elections, urging lawmakers to investigate the SpaceX founder and lay the groundwork for nationalizing his companies.”

“It should be a public corporation,” Reich says of SpaceX. “We should not ever have that kind of power in one person’s hands.”

Reich blithely sees no problem with that kind of power — along with far more potent varieties — being placed in the hands of Democrats like him.

N.B. The upper stage was safely captured in another of SpaceX’s state-of-the-art rocket-re-use landings. On schedule. SpaceX calls this technological procedure a catch, performed by the chopsticks on Mechazilla, the name of the tower.