An attempt to kill the right of statewide citizen initiative in Oklahoma has failed. By a 5-4 decision, the state supreme court ruled SB1027 unconstitutional and void.
Among other burdens, the legislation sought to require that no more than ten percent of petition signatures could come from a county with more than 400,000 residents.
KGOU reports that this cap would have been imposed on only two counties, those of Tulsa and Oklahoma, who together “could contribute only 20% of a petition’s signatures despite being home to nearly 37% of Oklahoma residents.”
We’re trying to get rural voters more involved, burbled bill backers. Also, petitioners who secure signatures from only a few counties are “corrupt,” asserted State Senator David Bullard.
The court’s decision notes that the “supposed goal of incorporating more rural voters at the signature gathering stage would impose a significant burden on the right of petition. The caps seek to achieve the inclusion of some by requiring the exclusion of others. . . . By denying qualified legal voters the right to participate in the petition process, the caps violate Oklahomans’ constitutional right of petition.”
A dissenting judge replied that no one who wanted to sign a petition would have been stopped by SB1027. It’s just that their valid signatures might have been tossed as irrelevant later . . . that’s all.
So the idea was you could sign. But it would have been as if you hadn’t were you one of those benighted post-ten percent signers.
. . . The virtue of which still eludes me.
This is Common Sense. I’m Paul Jacob.
Illustration created with Nano Banana
See all recent commentary
(simplified and organized)
See recent popular posts